Two Honest Prices

Essay · Where capability enters

Two Honest Prices

A banker wrote down in 1730 why the same work can carry two true prices at once. His law is running again — and this time the new money is capability.

  • John Rector
  • About a 6 minute read

The same website, the same week

$6,000 / $400

Two bids. Neither seller is lying.

One quote was written by the old cost of making. The other was written nearer the point where the new capability enters the economy. The distance between them is not fraud. It is time.

October 2026

You ask for two bids on redoing your website. The first comes back at $6,000 and three weeks. The second comes back at $400 and Friday. Your first instinct is that somebody is cheating you — the high one gouging, or the low one cutting corners. Sit with the stranger possibility: both are telling the truth. They are telling it from different years.

IThe banker who noticed

In 1730, give or take, a banker wrote down why this happens. Richard Cantillon was Irish, worked in Paris and London, and had made a fortune in the speculative frenzy around John Law’s paper money — made it and, more unusually, kept it, because he understood something his neighbors did not. He put it in a book: new money does not raise all prices at once. It enters the economy somewhere — a mine, a mint, a subsidy — and spreads outward, hand to hand. The first hands spend it while the shops still quote yesterday’s prices. By the time it reaches the last hands, every price has already moved. The first receivers get richer in real terms; the last receivers meet the new prices before they ever meet the new money.

Economists call this the Cantillon effect. Cantillon never saw it in print. His London house burned down in 1734 — most historians suspect murder — and the book, the Essai sur la Nature du Commerce en Général, appeared twenty-one years later, in 1755. When William Stanley Jevons rediscovered it more than a century after that, he called it the cradle of political economy. The cradle holds one sentence that matters this morning: where the new thing enters decides who gets rich.

IIA price is a memory

Why the lag? Why don’t prices simply jump to their new truth everywhere at once?

Because a price is not a fact about the thing. A price is a memory. It is what a market has learned to expect the thing to cost, trained on every transaction that market has ever witnessed. And nobody — no seller, no buyer, no committee — can edit that memory directly. I have written before that no entity can reach into an expectation and set it. The only road runs through the record: deals actually closed, one at a time, each one a small lesson, spreading outward from wherever the new deals happen first. That road is one-way and it is slow.

So the lag is not friction that better software will engineer away. The lag is the mechanism. The window between the new cost and the old price exists because expectations can only learn from history, and history takes time to make.

IIICapability is the new money

What is entering the economy now is not money. It is capability — and it is entering exactly the way Cantillon said money does. Not evenly, like weather. Injected, at a point: into the particular hands that actually wield it, daily, as a working habit rather than a subscription they hold.

For those hands, the cost of making has collapsed. Not the posted price — the cost. A website, an essay, a contract summary, a product catalog, a filing: each became an afternoon, then an hour, then a sentence of instruction. Meanwhile the prices those things carry were trained on decades in which the work cost a day of a person. The market’s memory has not caught up, because in most trades almost nobody near the spigot has transacted yet. Hence the two bids. Hence both honest.

Access is general. Advantage is positional — it is your distance from where capability enters, measured by the time your market takes to reprice.

This is the part the slogan hides. “Everyone has AI” is true of access and false of advantage. The subscription is universal; the wielding is not; and the gains in this window do not go to the smartest or even to the best. They go to the near. By construction the advantage is temporary — the wave passes, the market retrains, the spread closes. Which means the interesting question about any price you meet for the next several years is not is this fair? It is where was this written, and how long ago?

Figure 01 · The repricing wave

Capability enters at a point. Prices learn outward from it.

  • At the spigot daily wielders — cost collapses first
  • One handshake out their clients and competitors — repricing begins
  • The open market posted rates, menus, salaries — the long middle
  • Trust-gated work licensed, liable, accountable — reprices last, if at all
Bar length is time-to-reprice, drawn to make the argument’s shape visible — this is argument, not measured data. The hatched bar is the forecast I am least certain of: trust-gated work may hold its price indefinitely.
March 2027

A client reads your proposal, likes it, and asks the question nobody asked in 2024: “How long did this take you?” She is not making conversation. She is negotiating. She has her own estimate of what the work costs at the spigot now, and she wants to know how much of your price is work and how much of it is distance.

IVFive predictions

  1. Most deliverables will carry two honest prices for the rest of the decade.

    The spread between what a market still expects work to cost and what it costs near the spigot is the quiet margin of this era. It will build a class of small, local, unglamorous fortunes — and it will close one market at a time, never all at once.

  2. “How long did this take you?” becomes a price term.

    Buyers will learn to ask it the way they learned to ask about mileage. Provenance of effort will be negotiated into contracts, some sellers will answer with the old theater of billable hours, and the first disputes about honest answers will follow within a year.

  3. Repricing arrives in order of verifiability, not difficulty.

    Work whose quality a buyer can check in minutes — websites, copy, decks — reprices first. Work gated by license, liability, or standing holds its price longest, whatever it costs to produce. The hour that refuses to compress gets the raise; the license is a levee against the wave.

  4. Every model release restarts the wave.

    The spigot is not a place you win once. Each new capability is a fresh injection, and proximity is a practice — daily wielding — not a purchase. People who “got AI” in 2025 and stopped will meet 2028’s prices from the edge, like everyone else.

  5. The era’s resentment will be Cantillon’s, not the Luddites’.

    Not “the machine took my job” but “everything got cheaper to make and nothing I buy got cheaper.” That is exactly what the far edge of the wave feels like from inside — new prices arriving before the new capability does — and it will surface as a general mistrust of every invoice.

VLiving near the spigot

I should say plainly where I stand in this picture. I live near the spigot, and the window is my ordinary day. My stack drafted this page, built its cover, and published it before most offices opened — work the world’s memory still prices as a day of a person. And the business I run in Charleston is, described honestly, Cantillon’s: I stand nearer the point of entry than my clients do, and what I sell them is distance — I walk the capability one handshake out. I am not smarter than they are. I am nearer. In a few years that sentence will be worth much less, which is the strongest reason I know to act on it now.

VIThe claim, ledgered

Already true
Cantillon’s law is record: written around 1730, published 1755, rediscovered and named since. The collapse in making-cost for daily wielders is record too — this page is an instance of it. And posted prices across most services still quote the old cost of making; the two-bid experience is already common enough that you have probably had it.
What has to happen
Enough transactions at the new cost must accumulate, market by market, to retrain each price — expectations only learn from the record. Buyers must learn to ask about provenance and time. And capability must keep entering through hands rather than arriving evenly installed, which every release so far suggests it will.
Where I am probably wrong
The window may close far faster than 1730 suggests. Prices are posted in software now, and when agents buy from agents, the lag that creates the window could collapse toward zero — taking the positional advantage with it. And the opposite failure is live too: trust-gating may spread instead of shrinking, so that most prices never meet their costs. Then this is not a window but a new order of permanent spreads, and prediction three bends into something stranger.

Back to the two bids on your desk. Take either one; both are honest today. But the quote you receive next October will be written by whichever bidder stood nearer the spigot, and the one after that will be written nearer still. A price used to answer the question what is this worth? For the next few years it answers a different question.

Ask where it was written.

Author: John Rector

John Rector is a Charleston-based entrepreneur, author, and AI strategist. He co-founded E2open, the supply-chain software company acquired for $2.1 billion in 2025, and in 2026 opened Charleston AI, a 3,000-square-foot lab that helps people and organizations understand and use artificial intelligence. He is the creator of The Reality Equation — a lecture series, book, and curriculum exploring attention, prediction, and how reality is experienced — and the author of more than two dozen books. He writes and speaks widely on artificial intelligence, attention, and the future of human work.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.