Enough of Us

The Allee effect · when finding each other is free

Enough of us

Some groups only last above a certain size. Below it they shrink on their own. AI is about to lower that line for almost everything, except the part that needs us in the same room.

dN/dt = rN (N/A − 1)(1 − N/K)

A — today A — after AI shrinks on its own grows K group size →
The strong Allee effect. The group’s growth is negative below the threshold A and positive above it. Each loss below the line makes the next loss likelier. The dashed curve is the same group once finding each other and carrying the overhead cost almost nothing: the line moves left, but not to zero. The shape matters, not the numbers.

You are in a church hall with ten other singers and two of them are tenors. The director looks at the empty chairs, says nothing, and starts the warm-up anyway. You can all feel it: if one more tenor stops coming, the line will not hold, the music will stop working, and then other people will stop coming too.

Everyone who has kept a small group alive knows this feeling before they know its name. A book club, a congregation, a pickup game, a language spoken in a few kitchens. It is fine at twenty. It is fragile at eight. Somewhere around five it stops being a group that is shrinking and becomes a group that is ending, and nobody decided that. The arithmetic decided it.

The line under the group

In the 1930s an ecologist at the University of Chicago, Warder Clyde Allee, noticed that many animals do better together than alone. Goldfish in a crowded tank grew faster than goldfish kept singly. The idea that came out of his work is now called the Allee effect, and it is simple once you see it.

Members of a group do things for each other. They find each other. They share the fixed costs of being a group. They do things together that no one can do alone. All three get easier as the group gets bigger. So there is a size below which the members give each other less than staying costs them. Above that size the group grows. Below it the group shrinks, and each departure makes the next one more likely. Ecologists call that size the threshold. I will call it the line.

The line is true by structure, not by survey. It applies to anything whose members are worth more to each other in numbers: flocks, choirs, guilds, small towns, a dialect. One common reading of the passenger pigeon is exactly this. It did not need to be hunted to the last bird. It needed to be hunted below its line.

What AI changes: two of the three jobs

Look again at the three things members do for each other. AI changes their costs very differently.

  • Finding each otherWho else sings tenor, speaks the language, plays on Tuesdays. A personal AI can search the whole county for the ninth player while you sleep.
  • Carrying the overheadThe schedule, the dues, the sheet music, the reminders, the bookkeeping. The jobs that used to need a committee are now an afternoon.
  • Being there togetherThe second tenor voice in the room. The ten people needed for a game. The household where the language is spoken at dinner. This one does not get cheaper.

For most small groups, the first two jobs were most of the line. That is the good news, and it is large. The line falls, and it falls nearly everywhere. Groups that could not survive at seven people can survive at seven people now.

The non-obvious part is what the line becomes once it falls. It does not go to zero. It shrinks down to the third job, which is pure presence. All of a group’s fragility, which used to be spread across finding and paperwork and showing up, now sits in one place: whether enough people are physically there.

A machine can do a member’s work. It cannot be counted as a member.

And there is a trap inside the good news. AI can also stand in for the third job, or seem to. A speaker can sing the tenor part. A tutor can be your conversation partner in a language no one else in your town speaks. The group sounds full. It feels full. The line has not moved, though, because the line was never about the sound. It was about whether the people who are there have enough other people to stay for. A group that fills its empty chairs with machines can sit below its line for a long time without noticing, and then it is gone.

The choir never thinks about logistics anymore. The schedule runs itself, every singer has a practice track for their own part, and the AI found two new tenors in the next town over. Tonight there are fourteen people in the hall. Across the county, another choir has nine people and a very good speaker on the tenor line, and it sounds wonderful, and next spring it will have six.

What I expect

  1. Small groups multiply.

    Circles of five to thirty people that could not hold together before will hold together now: tiny congregations, craft guilds, study groups for rare subjects. The number of groups goes up even as the average size goes down.

  2. The room becomes the product.

    Organizers stop selling access to information and start selling the gathering itself. The measure that matters shifts from members on a list to people who came. A seat at a table with other people gets priced like a scarce thing, because it is one.

  3. Small languages get counted by conversations.

    AI tutors will produce many more learners of small languages. The communities that keep those languages alive will start counting something else: how many pairs of people speak it to each other, and how many homes speak it at dinner.

  4. Main Street splits by kind of line.

    A small-town shop whose minimum was overhead (ordering, books, staffing schedules) can now survive with fewer customers. A café whose minimum was being a place where people run into each other still needs the foot traffic. You will see the difference block by block.

  5. A new kind of collapse: busy and empty.

    Some groups will fill their gaps with machines and drop below their human line without noticing. The warning sign is a group with plenty of activity and fewer people every month. Once it is under the line, it shrinks on its own, the way small groups have before.

Where I stand in it

In January I opened a 3,000 square foot space in Charleston where people can come and learn to use AI. Everything we teach there can be learned alone, at home, from the same AI we teach. The room is there anyway. Last month I published a book on the French Huguenots of Charleston, a congregation of refugees that has kept going here for more than three centuries. Its church still stands downtown. That is what a group above its line looks like over a long time. I wrote about the other side of this in Narrow Enough to Live On: AI widens how far one person can reach. This piece is about what reach cannot replace.

The claim ledger

Already true
Groups below their size threshold decline on their own; this is old ecology and the experience of anyone who has run a small group. Finding people and running a group’s paperwork are already work a personal AI does well.
What has to happen
People have to use that freed effort to show up, not to stay home. Groups have to count who is in the room, not who is on the list, and treat a seat filled by a machine as an empty seat.
Where I am probably wrong
If people come to feel that a machine voice beside them is as good a reason to stay as a person, then presence was never the binding part of the line, and I have this backwards. I would know it if machine-filled groups hold their human members as well as human-filled ones, year after year.

The cost is plain. Some groups will die anyway, and some will die faster because they felt full the whole time.

Back in the church hall, the director is still counting chairs. The AI can find her a third tenor. It can print the music and send the reminders and teach him his part. It cannot stand in the second row on Thursday and hold the line. He has to walk in.

Enough of us means enough of us.

Background

  • W. C. Allee, Animal Aggregations: A Study in General Sociology, University of Chicago Press, 1931.
  • F. Courchamp, L. Berec and J. Gascoigne, Allee Effects in Ecology and Conservation, Oxford University Press, 2008.
  • John Rector, Narrow Enough to Live On.
  • John Rector, The French Huguenots of Charleston.

Author: John Rector

John Rector is a Charleston-based entrepreneur, author, and AI strategist. He co-founded E2open, the supply-chain software company acquired for $2.1 billion in 2025, and in 2026 opened Charleston AI, a 3,000-square-foot lab that helps people and organizations understand and use artificial intelligence. He is the creator of The Reality Equation — a lecture series, book, and curriculum exploring attention, prediction, and how reality is experienced — and the author of more than two dozen books. He writes and speaks widely on artificial intelligence, attention, and the future of human work.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.