For my students · Money & habit · Lesson 03
Move
your chair.
The tide has changed.
The advice hasn’t.

Imagine someone gives you this advice at the beach: every thirty minutes, pick up your chair and move it a little closer to the water.
You try it. It works. The tide is going out, and moving the chair keeps the water within reach. You bring your phone. You bring your snacks. Half an hour later, you do it again.
By the fifth move, you stop checking the tide. By the tenth, you are telling the person beside you how to do it.
Then the tide turns.
You keep moving toward the water. Same chair. Same beach. Same excellent advice. A wave comes through, and your phone and your snacks are on their way out to sea.
You did not forget the instructions. You forgot that the instructions depended on the tide.
Try the same advice twice
Change the tide.
Keep the habit.
The chair keeps moving toward the sea. Select the tide and watch what that same action means.
Moving closer preserves the distance you wanted. Repetition makes the instruction feel reliable.
The sea comes toward you while you move toward it. Your old routine is now working against your goal.
An illustration of a conditional rule. Financial cycles have no fixed lunar timetable.
01 / The long outgoing tide
Forty years can feel like forever.
In You Grew Up at Low Tide, I explained interest as the price of time. In Five Thousand Years of Tides, I widened the view. This lesson is about what happens inside your head when one financial environment lasts long enough to become normal.
Here is the history underneath it. From the early 1980s to 2020, U.S. interest rates followed a broad downward path. The ten-year Treasury yield averaged 15.32% in September 1981 and 0.62% in July 2020. Almost forty years of falling borrowing costs, measured from a historic high to an extraordinary low.
That does not mean rates fell every year. They rose sharply in parts of the 1980s, in 1994, and during later tightening cycles. The distinction matters: the long trend was down; the journey was uneven. Many people learned to treat an increase as an interruption on the way to cheaper money.
The environment that trained the advice
A lifetime inside one long descent.
At twenty-four, you did not personally experience that whole descent. You inherited it. The parents, advisers, property owners and commentators you listened to had spent much of their adult lives inside it.
Then you got your own concentrated dose. At fourteen, in 2016, you were starting to notice money. At eighteen, in 2020, the Fed returned its policy rate to near zero. At nineteen, in January 2021, Freddie Mac’s average thirty-year fixed mortgage rate reached 2.65%.
You also saw the reversal. The Fed’s target range went from near zero before its March 2022 increase to 5.25–5.50% in July 2023. But seeing a change on a screen is different from rebuilding the assumptions underneath your life.
The last ten years contain both the bottom and the turn. Much of the advice circulating through them carries the habits of the decades before.
02 / How a condition becomes a belief
Your experience becomes your definition of normal.
The first time a tactic works, you remember the result. After it works repeatedly, you compress the story. You stop saying, “This worked because financing became cheaper.” You start saying, “This is how wealth is built.”
The condition disappears. The instruction remains.
Economists Ulrike Malmendier and Stefan Nagel studied this tendency in Learning from Inflation Experiences. Their research found that people’s inflation expectations reflect the inflation they have lived through, with recent experience especially influential for younger people. The study concerns inflation expectations; I am applying the broader lesson to the financial habits we absorb.
You can know older history intellectually and still give the world you remember a privileged place in your decisions. For a young adult, a decade is most of the usable sample. For a successful adviser, forty years can feel like proof.
It is easy to see why the advice spreads. Falling rates can lower refinancing costs, lift the market price of existing fixed-rate bonds, and support higher valuations for future income. A person’s skill and the financial environment can improve the result together. Success alone does not tell you how much credit belongs to each.
03 / The missing condition
Listen for what the advice needs.
Take a familiar sentence: “Buy the house now. You can refinance later.” It sounds like a plan because an entire generation watched people do it.
Refinancing is a future transaction. It needs a rate that makes the costs worthwhile, a lender willing to lend, sufficient equity, and a borrower who still qualifies. If the original payment only works after that future rescue, the chair is already too close to the water.
Consider the scale. On an illustrative $300,000, thirty-year fixed loan, 2.65% means about $1,209 a month in principal and interest. At 7.28%, the same loan means about $2,053. The latter was Freddie Mac’s survey average on November 19, 2026. Taxes, insurance, fees and maintenance are additional. A future refinance can improve a workable purchase; it cannot be assumed into existence to make an unworkable one affordable.
Three inherited instructions
Find the invisible “if.”
“Cash is trash.”
The hidden condition: readily available safe returns are negligible. When rates rise, compare what cash can earn, after inflation and taxes, with what you need it to do. Emergency liquidity has a job even when its real return is poor.
“Bonds are safe.”
The hidden condition: you know which risk you mean. Credit quality and price stability are different. When market yields rise, existing fixed-rate bond prices generally fall; longer maturities tend to be more sensitive. The SEC’s explanation of interest-rate risk makes this distinction explicit.
“Borrow and let the asset pay you back.”
The hidden condition: the asset produces enough cash, financing remains manageable, and you can survive a bad stretch. Appreciation is uncertain. Debt payments arrive on a schedule. A plan that needs both rising prices and cheaper replacement debt depends on two favors from the tide.
Higher rates do not raise the payment on an existing fixed-rate loan. They matter when you take a new loan, refinance, or face a variable-rate reset. That difference explains why two neighbors can live in similar houses and inhabit very different financial worlds.
Nor does a rate increase mechanically make every stock or house fall. Earnings, rents, supply and demand still matter. The change is that cheapening money can no longer be quietly entered in the plan as a dependable helper.
04 / Read the water
A wave can retreat while the tide comes in.
This is how I see the environment now: the long outgoing tide that trained those habits has ended. We are living with the return of a meaningful price for money. The ten-year Treasury averaged 5.13% in October 2026, far above its 2020 floor.
That is a view of the environment, not a claim that every interest rate must rise every month. A central bank can cut short-term rates while long-term borrowing remains expensive. Inflation expectations, the demand for capital and the compensation lenders require for risk affect the rates you actually face.
Financial tides are irregular. There is no published time for the next high water. If rates fall next quarter, that observation belongs in your thinking. It does not, by itself, establish that the world of 2020 has returned.
The practical shift is to make plans that work at the financing costs available to you, and to retain room if those costs rise. Treat a better rate as an improvement when it becomes available. Give savings, liquidity and current cash flow their proper place again.
Some lessons travel across tides: spend less than you earn, diversify, understand costs, and match your commitments to your resources. Keep them. Examine the extra promises that accumulated around them: guaranteed appreciation, an automatic rebound, a refinance right on time.
Before your next financial decision
Ask the beach chair question.
What has to keep happening for this advice to work?
Then ask: if it stops happening, can I still keep the chair, the phone and the snacks?
Try it: “The payment is a stretch, but rates should fall.”
The purchase depends on cheaper financing arriving before the stretched budget fails. Start by judging the payment you can contract for today, your reserves and your other obligations. The hoped-for rate is a possible improvement, rather than the foundation of affordability.
You do not need to predict the exact peak to recognize that your routine was built for falling water. You need to notice the condition, test the advice against it, and change your action when the condition changes.
Before you move the chair again,
look at the water.